November 19, 2026 · Global health

The missing ‘how’: what the candidates for WHO Director-General have not yet explained

Sculpture of paper chrysalises turning into butterflies on a wire, symbolizing organizational transformation

At the Geneva Learning Foundation, we have just released six proposals for the candidates for Director-General of the World Health Organization. The agenda paper is called “From guidance to results”. You can find it on learning.foundation, in all six official languages of the United Nations.

Most platforms published so far by candidates commit WHO to results that people can see in their countries. So how do norms and standards from the World Health Organization get put to use in the district hospital, the rural health post, the city clinic? And how can we measure that?

What we propose in the paper is that WHO operate a two-way, double-loop learning system. Guidance should reach the people who deliver health services, within national priorities. The missing piece is what happens next. What they learn applying it should return to their peers, laterally, across borders and across job roles. It should also go upward to their ministry, and then back to WHO, fast enough that what they learn through practice improves practice everywhere and strengthens the evidence base. In the words of the paper: “The global health system moves directives down efficiently. It moves learning up poorly.” All six proposals aim to change that.

The proposals can be stated modestly. They are all within the bounds of what WHO already does, as agreed by Member States, so there is no need to change the architecture. A change in architecture would help, yes. It would make the proposals easier to implement.

We ground each proposal in our actual experience at the Geneva Learning Foundation of implementing systems that do what the proposal asks WHO to do. We also spell out the consequences if each proposal is not implemented, to show why it addresses a significant gap, and we define the gaps by their impact on health outcomes. There is an open question about the level of evidence for the theory of change by which WHO’s normative standards lead to improved health outcomes. But back to the six proposals.

What is the legitimacy of these proposals?

Beyond the six proposals, the paper highlights what happens if the gaps we identify are not closed, and sets out tangible actions the new Director-General could carry out in the first 100 days.

What makes the Geneva Learning Foundation legitimate to make such proposals? We invested a decade of research and implementation, working with ministries of health and international partners and focusing on the sub-national, service delivery level, with a network of over 80,000 health and humanitarian workers. We asked how things change if we look at implementers as leaders, if we find a route to turn guidelines into action and then feed back how to improve them, and if we listen and find new ways to support implementation and follow-up. We have trialled, explored, and piloted many of the things that go into the proposals. That is why we believe the candidates should give them due consideration.

Our mission is to research new ways to learn and lead, to survive the critical threats our societies face. Threats to health have been our focus for the first decade. We believe in a network built from the district up, and we hope this will be a useful contribution to the thinking of the candidates.

They all say they want to see WHO’s work turned into results that people can see in countries. What is missing is the how, the actual mechanism. It is tempting to say that this is the job of countries. In the globalized, hyper-connected world we live in, that no longer needs to be the case. And saying so strengthens country sovereignty and country ownership.

1. Publish major guidelines with a route to use them and improve them

Right now, a lot of WHO guidelines sit on a shelf or, more likely, on a web page on the WHO website. The resources to put them to use are often very limited. There may be a workshop or, if you are lucky, a series of workshops. Yet that is where we think the best available global knowledge should be put to use.

The second part of the proposal, improving them, is double-loop learning. It means establishing a mechanism, and the paper has a clear, simple proposal for how to do that. In many ways, this is the most radical of the six, because double-loop learning also implies questioning your governing values. That may seem a harsh way for an institution to call itself into question, but I believe it would be the most fundamental change.

2. Set standards for rapid listening and implementation methods that ministries own

If we are going to improve global knowledge by mobilizing, recognizing, and valuing local knowledge, we need to set standards for that. It cannot be an ad hoc process.

Today it happens, but it is a messy process. Something a nurse does, the district medical officer will pick up on. It will make it back to the national authorities somehow. Maybe a national planner will be in a WHO workshop, and somehow it makes it into a guideline. We can do better than that in this century, when we have data, artificial intelligence, and the humans to facilitate these processes and to validate them.

3. Support countries to develop local health staff as leaders of implementation

Many countries still have a very vertical, command-and-control system. National planners set the strategy and build the plan. Health staff, especially at the service delivery level, are seen as implementers. That is not a slur. In a well-functioning system, they are really good at implementing. But leadership is a distinct question.

The shift from implementer to leader of implementation means recognizing that health staff make decisions and analyse situations, often with very limited information. At the end of the day, that is what determines whether a child is vaccinated or not.

In August, the Geneva Learning Foundation published its leadership framework for local health leadership, which describes what we are talking about. It comes, like each proposal, from doing things, learning from them, and making sense of the data on what these actions do for health outcomes.

4. Focus climate and health action on measurable health outcomes

A very interesting movement has emerged, driven by pioneers who have advocated, in some cases for decades, for the climate crisis to be understood, correctly I believe, as a health crisis. That movement has reached a point where there is a lot of evidence, momentum for action, and growing recognition of the health impacts. Massive investments have built a whole field of high-quality academic research. The biggest gap we see is how health action on the impacts of climate change leads to improved health outcomes.

We started our climate and health programme at the Geneva Learning Foundation three years ago. What we have learned is that local solutions exist. People on the ground are implementing them out of necessity. When there is a flood, a heatwave, or any of the extreme weather events that climate change is making more frequent, health actors respond, and communities respond. What we are missing is a way to discern what makes a difference to health outcomes. What kind of difference does it make? How do we know, and how do we measure it?

So we published the 7-30 Climate-Health Emergency Framework, grounded in the experiences shared by thousands of people who work for health. We believe it is an example of a new kind of knowledge and a new way to produce it, a new epistemology, how we know what we know, that leads to tangible ways to measure health outcomes.

5. Facilitate and strengthen a shared capability system connecting ministries and pre-service institutions

Johns Hopkins School of Public Health is a 4 billion dollar a year institution. By comparison, the investment in the WHO Academy was announced as 100 million euros from the government of France, and that was a promise, not 100 million on the table.

Pre-service institutions form a system of systems: schools of medicine, nursing, midwifery, the allied professions, and so on. The gap we see is the connections between them and the needs of countries. We do not see WHO’s role as building an academy, its own school of public health. We do not think that makes sense. WHO should be the connector, the facilitator between pre-service institutions and the needs of countries. So we call for a review of the WHO Academy and how it best fits. Closing that gap is critically important.

6. Make the judgment of the health workforce part of WHO’s approach to responsible artificial intelligence

This proposal is about what we call the validation tether: the need for humans who can judge the quality of what artificial intelligence outputs.

Sure, you can go into the free version of ChatGPT and ask it to develop a national policy for midwifery. Who is going to make sense of the output? You need validation. People become good at validation through practice and experience, and of course through formal learning and technical knowledge. But practice and experience count far more than we acknowledge. That is a key focus of our research at the Geneva Learning Foundation.

As a junior professional, you get stuck with reviewing long documents, and gradually you build up those capabilities. If that grunt work is handed off to artificial intelligence, the prediction is that by 2035 or 2040, there will be no one left who can make those judgments. The next Director-General should ensure that Member States continue to invest in the professional development of the health workforce, which remains responsible for what comes out of artificial intelligence systems.

Get access to the latest opportunities

Subscribe now to receive the latest opportunities from The Geneva Learning Foundation (TGLF).

We first request your permission to send you email. Please look for this secure e-mail in your inbox and click on the safe link it contains.